Would You Pay $6,000 to Save the Life of Your Elderly Dog?

A recent New York Times article asked that very question -- and received many harsh comments.


This week, Roz Warren — a mild-mannered librarian, humorist and dog lover — wrote a piece for the New York Times about the price one is willing to pay to save a sick elderly dog.

In her case, she was paying for her son’s 13-year-old Bichon Frise, who needed emergency gallbladder surgery, which carried a 30 percent chance of life-threatening post-op complications. The surgery cost $6,000. If it was successful, it would give the old dog maybe two more years.

Warren writes of the dog owners, “Tom and Amy are crazy about these dogs, so much so that when they married, both Bichons were included in the ceremony. Max, part of Amy’s life since her folks brought him home when she was 12, was the ring bearer. Jack was the ‘flower dog.’

“Jack and Max aren’t just dogs,” she continues, “they’re regarded as beloved family members. And when a beloved family member needs life-saving surgery, you don’t sit back and ‘let nature take its course.’ You take him to a hospital.”

The author immediately volunteered to pay a third of the cost, knowing how much the dog meant to everybody. Then she told her friends. Opinion was mixed.

“He’s an old dog,” one chided. “You’re missing an opportunity to teach your son a valuable life lesson. There comes a time when you have to let go.”

Another said she’d do the same “in a heartbeat.”

Another said, “When it’s time to go, it’s time to go. You grieve. Then you get another dog. Preferably from a shelter.”

Regardless, the family took the dog in for surgery. Unfortunately, there were complications. “Max came through the operation beautifully,” the vet told them. “But his gall bladder had already ruptured.”

And yet Max not only survived, but thrived. After spending 24 hours in the canine intensive-care unit, with his own round-the-clock I.C.U. nurse, he bounced back quickly.

“We paid the whopping hospital bill with no regrets. Max, alive and well, is worth every penny. Even if he hadn’t made it through, knowing that we had done all we could for him would have been worth that price.”

The story closed, and we were happy. Then we started reading the comments. There was a heck of a fight going on in there. While many shared our feelings and said they would have done the same as the author, plenty of others said that spending that kind of money on a dog was crazy. They also bashed the notion that we should even love our dogs. Here’s some of them:

This article is utterly offensive. People are starving in our own country, yet Ms. Warren proudly defends spending $6,000 to attend to a dog.

I’m sorry but, I think it’s disgusting to even consider spending $6,000 to save the life of a pet when there are children all around the world (including many parts of the USA) who need life-saving medical treatments or operations.

This pet obsession in America is insane. Sorry to sound insensitive, but a dog is not your child.

Pets are great, but they are not people. They don’t think. They don’t “love” you. They are not a replacement for humans.

Strong stuff. Also way off-base — but that’s no surprise in the hornet’s nest of a major newspaper’s comment section.

We’re curious what Dogster readers think, so we’re bringing the same question to you that Roz Warren brought to her friends: “Would you pay $6,000 for a 70 percent chance of buying two extra years of life for an elderly dog?” And if you’ve had a similar experience, please tell us about it in the comments!

2 thoughts on “Would You Pay $6,000 to Save the Life of Your Elderly Dog?”

  1. I appreciate and I am very thankful for your blessing! My baby boy will enjoy wearing it all. I am just a single mom going through a hard time right now. I was drawing unemployment until i came across Finance Now, and due to complications while pregnant I’m unable to work while pregnant. Every piece of money I get goes towards bills. I was so worried about items for my baby. Your gifts makes me feel alot better! Thanks again! Share your thought with finance now on your financial problem and get good interest loan today via call / Text / whatsApp +1 4313007649

    I hope this information has helped.

  2. My mother loaned me over $5000.00 recently for an MRI,EKG and additional tests/lab work when my precious pomeranian, Bailey, suffered a stroke and two subsequent grand mal seizures in April. He had just turned 15. We never even considered any other option. Though he sustained some neurological damage and has to take be medicated several times per day, he made a full recovery and has plenty of life in him yet! He still loves to play and run ,occasionally dragging my fiancee and I on walks!! I have zero regrets and frequently think to myself how every penny was well spent. My dog is my world. He’s my child, my best friend. I’d give him a kidney if he needed one!!! I know I can’t prevent him from one day crossing the rainbow bridge but I vow to do everything in my power to ensure he has the longest, healthiest, happiest life as long as he is capable. This is the promise we make when we bring them into our lives (or at least it should be in my opinion).

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Dogster in your inbox!

Stay informed! Get tips and exclusive deals.

Let Dogster answer all of your most baffling canine questions!

Starting at just

This error message is only visible to WordPress admins
There has been a problem with your Instagram Feed.


Follow Us

Shopping Cart